I'm Not a Baby - Hardcover

*Starred Review* PreS-Gr. 2. With a sense of theater borrowed from Maurice Sendak and McElmurry's own idiosyncratic approach to color, pattern, and story, the creator of Mad about Plaid (2000) introduces a memorable character: Leo Leotardi, whose distracted Edwardian family clings to the notion that their youngest remains a baby. The book opens as toddler Leo climbs from his flounced bassinet and asks for waffles, only to be sternly rebuffed and presented with porridge. Later episodes show him clad in infants' togs and enduring cooing remarks ("What a clever baby!") even as he attends school, gives a graduation speech, and starts his first job. McElmurry adds surreal touches to the ornate, period settings that suit the farce: odd colors dominate (pea green, salmon pink); word-bubbles introduce a comic-book informality into the stately compositions; and occasional, anachronistic elements appear, such as one character's high-top sneakers. Balancing the visual cacophony is a restrained text, evoking the calcified family dynamics in episodes that follow the same basic pattern, always ending with Leo's child-pleasing battle cry: "I am NOT a baby!" When a real baby--Leo's own--finally evaporates the myth, the resolution feels a bit abrupt; nonetheless, children will be deeply amused by the premise, and wholly sympathetic to the frustrations of being labeled, patronized, or willfully misunderstood. Pair this with Simon James' Baby Brains: The Smartest Baby in the World (2004). Jennifer Mattson
Copyright © American Library Association. All rights reserved

Starred Review. PreSchool-Grade 2–Leo Leotardi has a problem, and it's plainly stated by the title and cover art. I'm not a baby! declaims the indignant child in a fussy Victorian pram, preposterously attired in rompers, a ruffle-edged baby bonnet, and booties. As he progresses through life–from tricycling off to school in his rompers, to his graduation speech in which he declares independence from booties and blankies, to his entry into the workforce (his nanny tying his bonnet under his manly chin), to his marriage and fatherhood–Leo's family continues to call him the baby against all his protestations (framed by speech balloons). It is when his own infant calls Leo Dada that his aging family awakens to reality. It is left to Leo's doting nanny to toss off the final absurdity, Who ever said he was a baby? The story has a child-appealing arc: the visual humor escalates as poor Leo looks more and more ludicrous in his baby clothes, and the predictable patterning of his repeated objections will invite ever-louder participation from listeners. The gouache illustrations on cream-colored paper present Leo's feckless family in a kind of Victorian tableau. The universality of Leo's lament and its wonderfully silly treatment will elicit giggles of recognition and, no doubt, requests for repeated readings.–Kate McClelland, Perrot Memorial Library, Old Greenwich, CT
Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved.